Drafted by
python -m cygnus.campaign reportfrom the runner's outputs; reviewed 2026-09-25. The escalation and reviewer notes below were added by hand; every other number is the runner's.
Escalation (2026-09-25)#
The positive control formally failed at a covered epoch (BJD 2458722.3937; 262 usable cadences), despite a measured depth of 392 ± 31 ppm being consistent with the 368-ppm catalogue value. The per-light-curve k* = 4 calibration has a 90%-completeness depth of 5000 ppm at the longest tabulated duration (8 h), while the transit is 8.73 h and 368 ppm; it is far below tested sensitivity. Record this as a sensitivity-limited pipeline failure, not a wrong-epoch inference. No threshold or state was changed. Next: verify the TOI/SPOC DV epoch and compare an independent reduction that can measure a few-hundred-ppm signal.
- Campaign spec:
campaigns/toi-2436-01.yaml - Parent queue:
tess-mono-01 - Ledger runs: calibrate_screen #418, fetch_products #417, known_signal_recovery #419, period_aliases #421, prior_art #422, residual_screen #420
- Runner finished (UTC): 2026-09-25T05:37:36Z
Bottom line#
Positive control failed: BJD 2458722.3937: not recovered, depth 392 ± 31 ppm (catalogue 368 ppm). Outside the catalogued epoch the screen left 100 threshold entries forming 41 distinct event(s), 0 persistent (SAP and PDCSAP, two or more baselines). None is vetted; see Screen events.
This is a pipeline check on a known object, not a discovery claim. No period is implied by a single transit.
Reviewer notes (2026-09-25, supersede pass)#
Superceded by the multi-archive runner: re-run through python -m cygnus.multi on 2026-09-25, steps fetch_products, calibrate_screen, known_signal_recovery, residual_screen, period_aliases, prior_art (ledger fetch_products #1447, calibrate_screen #1448, known_signal_recovery #1449, residual_screen #1450, period_aliases #1451, prior_art #1452). Same retrieved products, same science outputs: entries, depths, k-star calibration and aliases match the production-runner results recorded here; the multi runner additionally records a screen-suitability census and a red-noise systematics model per light curve. The record is regenerated by the multi runner; nothing in the review changes.
Reviewer notes (2026-09-25)#
Positive control failed formally with the epoch covered in sector 15 (262 usable in-transit cadences; QUALITY=0, max gap 2 min): measured 392 ± 31 ppm vs catalogue 368 ppm (ratio 1.07), a depth-consistent broad signal. The sector's k* = 4 90%-completeness depth is 5000 ppm at the longest tabulated duration (8 h; 2000 ppm for 1–4 h); the 368-ppm, 8.73-h catalogue event is far below the tested floor. Do not infer a wrong ephemeris or tune the threshold.
There are 0 persistent events among 100 threshold entries / 41 groups. Report rows are mostly brief, single-flux SAP excursions; no repeated feature survives both SAP and PDCSAP. The check remains a bounded pipeline test with no candidate. NASA Exoplanet Archive, TOI, VSX and SIMBAD all answered; no VSX variable match. Pixel/difference-image, pointing and alternate-reduction tests remain not tested.
Target#
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| name | TOI-2436.01 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| tic | 154568734 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| ra_deg | 191.297899 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| dec_deg | 72.123084 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| t0_bjd | 2458722.393707 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| depth_ppm | 367.8233419 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| duration_h | 8.7302689 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| tmag | 8.55595 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| catalogue_row_updated | 2022-11-15 16:02:02 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
Products#
| Product | Sector | Covers catalogued epoch | SHA-256 (first 16) | Retrieved now |
|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2019226182529-s0015-0000000154568734-0151-s_lc.fits | 15 | True | 4ca450696044712a | True |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 14 | False | 91fe777953f54a78 | True |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 21 | False | 5e4b810b7ff73be8 | True |
tess2021175071901-s0040-0000000154568734-0211-s_lc.fits | 40 | False | 275c0ab3c042e643 | True |
tess2021204101404-s0041-0000000154568734-0212-s_lc.fits | 41 | False | d29cd6c3487486a3 | True |
tess2021364111932-s0047-0000000154568734-0218-s_lc.fits | 47 | False | 398330d371b515c9 | True |
Positive control (catalogued transit)#
| Product | Epoch (BJD) | State | Usable in-transit cadences | Measured depth (ppm) | Catalogue depth (ppm) | Entry offset (h) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2019226182529-s0015-0000000154568734-0151-s_lc.fits | 2458722.39371 | not_recovered | 262 | 392 ± 31 | 368 | — |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 368 | — |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 368 | — |
tess2021175071901-s0040-0000000154568734-0211-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 368 | — |
tess2021204101404-s0041-0000000154568734-0212-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 368 | — |
tess2021364111932-s0047-0000000154568734-0218-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 368 | — |
Depth: median PDCSAP residual inside ±duration/2 about the catalogued epoch, against a 2-d running median; the error is statistical only. A depth unlike the catalogue's may reflect dilution, detrending or an epoch/duration error; it is reported, not used as a pass mark.
Calibration and sensitivity#
| Product | k* (sign-flip null) | At grid floor | 90 % completeness depth at k = 5, by duration | at k* |
|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2019226182529-s0015-0000000154568734-0151-s_lc.fits | 4 | False | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 | 1h: 2000, 2h: 2000, 4h: 2000, 8h: 5000 |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2 | True | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 | 1h: 2000, 2h: 2000, 4h: 2000, 8h: 2000 |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 4 | False | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 |
tess2021175071901-s0040-0000000154568734-0211-s_lc.fits | 3 | False | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 | 1h: 2000, 2h: 2000, 4h: 2000, 8h: 2000 |
tess2021204101404-s0041-0000000154568734-0212-s_lc.fits | 4 | False | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 |
tess2021364111932-s0047-0000000154568734-0218-s_lc.fits | 4 | False | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 | 1h: 2000, 2h: 2000, 4h: 2000, 8h: 2000 |
The null result (if any) excludes only dips deeper than the 90 %-completeness depth for their duration.
Screen events outside the catalogued epoch#
Entries merged where they overlap in time. Persistent = SAP and PDCSAP at two or more baselines.
| Product | Mid time (BJD) | Deepest median residual | Max cadences | Flux | Baselines (d) | Persistent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 2458895.39726 | -0.00418 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 2458887.17648 | -0.00394 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 2458895.44032 | -0.00369 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 2458887.57509 | -0.00353 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 2458887.39037 | -0.00344 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 2458887.31260 | -0.00342 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 2458894.55699 | -0.00309 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458687.94515 | -0.00308 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2020020091053-s0021-0000000154568734-0167-s_lc.fits | 2458893.78478 | -0.00306 | 2 | SAP | 1 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458693.43122 | -0.00302 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458703.17009 | -0.00297 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458690.64374 | -0.00287 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458708.40621 | -0.00283 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019226182529-s0015-0000000154568734-0151-s_lc.fits | 2458719.63687 | -0.00274 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458697.75690 | -0.00259 | 3 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458699.04092 | -0.00253 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458684.29797 | -0.00252 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458708.52566 | -0.00252 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458697.45412 | -0.00251 | 3 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458684.44797 | -0.00250 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458691.85206 | -0.00246 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458688.06112 | -0.00244 | 3 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458702.36870 | -0.00243 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458698.02704 | -0.00240 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458683.59868 | -0.00229 | 3 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458696.30343 | -0.00225 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458705.32565 | -0.00215 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458688.30626 | -0.00211 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458708.19788 | -0.00210 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458697.56454 | -0.00210 | 2 | SAP | 2 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458683.43271 | -0.00208 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458697.92148 | -0.00207 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458684.08409 | -0.00204 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458683.44798 | -0.00199 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458706.35065 | -0.00197 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458709.85067 | -0.00196 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458698.25620 | -0.00192 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458689.05903 | -0.00191 | 2 | SAP | 1 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458683.64381 | -0.00157 | 2 | PDCSAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458683.57298 | -0.00156 | 2 | PDCSAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2019198215352-s0014-0000000154568734-0150-s_lc.fits | 2458690.89791 | -0.00144 | 2 | PDCSAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
None has been vetted: centroids, pointing, background, momentum dumps and other reductions are not tested. Most screen events in TESS light curves are systematics; each is at most an unverified lead.
Catalogue cross-match#
TOI-2436.01
- NASA_Exoplanet_Archive (done, 2026-09-25): no match in NASA_Exoplanet_Archive within 30" as of 2026-09-25T05:37:30Z
- TESS_TOI (done, 2026-09-25): 1 match(es) in TESS_TOI within 30" as of 2026-09-25T05:37:32Z: TOI-2436.01 (TIC 154568734, disposition PC)
- VSX (done, 2026-09-25): no match in VSX within 30" as of 2026-09-25T05:37:34Z
- SIMBAD (done, 2026-09-25): 1 match(es) in SIMBAD within 30" as of 2026-09-25T05:37:35Z: BD+72 581 (PM*)
Checks#
| Check | State | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Product integrity (SHA-256) | passed | 6 product(s) checksummed at first retrieval |
| Known-signal recovery (positive control) | failed | BJD 2458722.3937: not recovered, depth 392 ± 31 ppm (catalogue 368 ppm) |
| Calibrated false-alarm threshold (sign-flip null) | passed | screen run at each light curve's own k* (3.5, ≤2.5, 3.5, 3, 4.5, 3.5; ≤ 0 persistent null events outside the veto) |
| Synthetic signal injection–recovery | inconclusive | completeness for the reference box (2000ppm_4h) at each light curve's k*: 100%, 100%, 80%, 100%, 20%, 90% (pass mark 90%); 90%-completeness depths are in calibration.json |
| Catalogue cross-match | passed | 1 target(s) × 4 services, radius 30″; 4 answered, 0 errored; results in the ledger prior_art table |
| Period aliases (repeat events) | not_tested | catalogued transit not recovered; no reference depth |
| Alternative detrending | not_tested | |
| Difference-image centroids / blend audit | not_tested | |
| Pointing / jitter correlation | not_tested | |
| Literature (ADS) audit | not_tested |
Reproduction#
python -m cygnus.campaign run campaigns/toi-2436-01.yaml
python -m cygnus.campaign report campaigns/toi-2436-01.yaml
Addendum 2026-09-26: suite-expansion checks#
Re-run on 2026-09-26 with the steps added by the suite expansion (docs/SUITE_EXPANSION.md §7.3) and the corrected moving-object check (TESS-centred SkyBoT positions, distance-aware). The earlier science outputs (screen, calibration, positive control, aliases, cross-match) were compared leaf by leaf and are unchanged apart from timestamps. States and notes below are copied from sky_record.json; the review above is not changed by them unless a note says so.
| Check | State | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Target-to-Gaia identification (proper motion propagated) | passed | TOI-2436.01: Gaia DR3 1689544206152233472 at 0.00" (propagated 2016.0 → J2015.5; 0.03" unpropagated, proper-motion shift 0.03") |
| Stellar priors (Gaia colour and parallax) | passed | TOI-2436.01: Teff 6287 K, R* 1.23 ± 0.10, M* 1.18 ± 0.12, ρ* 0.63 ± 0.16 ρ☉ (dwarf sequence, M_G 3.87, no extinction) |
| Blend and dilution census (Gaia DR3 cone) | inconclusive | TOI-2436.01: 3 Gaia neighbour(s) within 52.5", contamination 0.44%; depth 368 ppm (catalogue depth); 2 could produce it if fully eclipsed (brightest 1689543896915487616, 51.3", ΔG 6.00); a centroid test is needed |
| Pointing and quality census per event | not_tested | no persistent screen event outside the veto |
| Moving objects at screen-event epochs | not_tested | no persistent screen event outside the veto |
| Variable-catalogue collision (VSX) | passed | TOI-2436.01: no VSX entry within 10" |
| Object-class guard (SIMBAD) | passed | TOI-2436.01: BD+72 581 otype PM* (star_or_other) at 1.1" |
| Independent repetition (other MAST collections) | not_tested | no repeat candidate with allowed period aliases |
| Independent-epoch confirmation (ZTF) | not_tested | no repeat candidate with allowed period aliases |
failed on the per-event census means at least one persistent screen event carries an in-event artifact flag or pointing shift (event_census.json); it is a statement about those events, not about the catalogued signal.