Candidate dossiers · 3 published

Candidates

A dossier records one signal and everything done to try to explain it away. Its evidence level describes how far it has survived those tests — not how interesting it is.

Ranked by evidence level, then working ID. Ranking is by evidence only; calibrated scientific scoring is not yet implemented.
Working IDEvidenceAuditBottom lineNext test
CYG-2026-09-TOI224.01 Unverified lead 7 passed
4 failed
8 inconclusive
4 not tested
A new Sector107 FFI dip repeats near the conditional 31.57966184-day timing family, but its 0.618-arcsec displacement at a 4.71 block-bootstrap ratio leaves localization inconclusive. Gaia records a 49.801-km/s robust RV range over21 accepted transits, GOF41.54 and RUWE9.18; SOAR literature resolves a close companion and favors an eclipsing binary. S106 remains rejected. A clean single-star planet interpretation is unsupported; which component eclipses and its orbit remain unresolved. Unverified lead. Resolve the S107 significant subpixel displacement with component-aware PRF/registration and same-CCD/pointing controls. Obtain or recover phase-spread component velocities; fit a binary orbit before assigning the eclipse or companion mass. New repeat timing alone is insufficient.
CYG-2026-09-TOI2666.01 Unverified lead 11 passed
4 failed
4 inconclusive
7 not tested
S35/S99 V-shaped dips persist under independent baseline choices. Zhang2024 primary Keck/HIRES evidence identifies HIP45621/TOI2666 as a spectroscopic binary with35-km/s component separation, corroborating the close-companion alternative. The later eclipse is not linked to a solved stellar orbit. Earlier S8 FFI tests robustly exclude0 of52 historical aliases across exposure integration and timing slack; noisy reductions cannot supply a clean nondetection. Unverified event interpretation; binarity independently established. Two public FEROS spectra from2006/2009 were retrieved; their relative-shift blocks disagree by53km/s, so no usable component velocities or orbit are claimed. A bounded public Keck HIRES coordinate query returns three raw observations from1998/2021; exact-name selection returns zero. Documented public access recovered all three primary header prefixes: each TARGNAME is80133, consistent with intended HD80133 targeting. Iodine is out for1998/February2021 and in forMay2021. KOA lists18/59/58 associated calibrations; suitability, acquired component identity and component velocities remain untested. No full science or calibration FITS was downloaded; no extra velocities or orbit are claimed. Recover multi-epoch component spectra/RVs of HD80133/HIP45621 and fit an SB2 orbit against the observed eclipse times. No S8 alias exclusion is robust; do not restore a single-star radius or infer a planet from the light curve alone. Screen the three public KOA raw observations for exact-source identity and science-grade calibration before extracting component velocities.
CYG-2026-09-TOI3500.02 Unverified lead 11 passed
5 failed
8 inconclusive
6 not tested
S64/S90 dips persist, but official UPDATED_2.0 TESS PRFs do not assign the deficit robustly between the0.18-pixel-separated Gaia A/B pair. Source preference reverses with allowed registration and1/3/5-percent model floors; static PRF residuals exceed nominal interpolation accuracy. S101 remains rejected and supplies no period preference. All16 baseline aliases remain open; Gaia RV summaries provide no orbit or companion-mass bound. Unverified lead. Six public HARPS epochs span111.785days with87.507m/s corrected-RV range. A conditional circular50.0446-day fit gives signedK about39m/s but six epochs, line-width correlation and unresolved source identity prevent confirmation or alias rejection. Eighteen further HARPS and six FEROS products returnHTTP401. A relative-spectrum attempt on23 FEROS and6 HARPS spectra fails the independent HARPS precision check (168m/s RMS); derived shifts are not accepted orbital velocities. A completed31-input line-mask rerun gives HARPS CCF-alignment disagreement RMS10.9458m/s (R50G2) and10.8503m/s (K0), both failing the10m/s requirement. FEROS midpoint barycentric replacement deltas are roughly-103 to+173m/s; release products also lack simultaneous-reference drift correction and usable ERR arrays. FEROS profile shifts remain unvalidated. Use validated empirical sector PRFs or resolved time-series photometry for A/B; seek another clean event or component RV series. Retain all16 aliases, exclude S101 from period evidence, and do not treat catalog RV range as an orbital semiamplitude. Improve and validate line-mask/continuum spectral RV extraction; test the50.0446-day hypothesis against activity and blended components using additional accessible spectra.