Historical analysis below. Current evidence and dossier: 2026-09-30 follow-up. S64/S90 dips persist, but official UPDATED_2.0 TESS PRFs do not assign the deficit robustly between the0.18-pixel-separated Gaia A/B pair. Source preference reverses with allowed registration and1/3/5-percent model floors; static PRF residuals exceed nominal interpolation accuracy. S101 remains rejected and supplies no period preference. All16 baseline aliases remain open; Gaia RV summaries provide no orbit or companion-mass bound. Unverified lead.
2026-09-27 verification update: Canonical dossier units, local-null claims and difference-image states were corrected. New live MAST/TOI metadata and independent cached-TPF checks are linked from the follow-up report. A two-source Gaussian-PSF sensitivity grid usually favors the target in S64/S90 but reverses under plausible PSF/registration choices because the target and 3.71-arcsec companion are only 0.184 TESS pixel apart; localization remains inconclusive. Older interpretations below are historical where they conflict.
Generated draft (
python -m cygnus.campaign report). Numbers are copied from the runner's saved outputs; the interpretation lines are templates. Review againstdocs/AGENT_RUNBOOK.md, edit, and delete the first line (the draft marker) once reviewed.
- Campaign spec:
campaigns/toi-3500-02.yaml - Parent queue:
tess-mono-01 - Ledger runs: calibrate_screen #122, fetch_products #121, known_signal_recovery #123, period_aliases #125, prior_art #126, residual_screen #124
- Runner finished (UTC): 2026-09-25T00:49:04Z
Escalation (2026-09-25 — repeat candidate found)#
period_aliases flagged 15 repeat candidates (persistent PDCSAP+SAP events within 0.5–2× of the catalogued transit depth). Per docs/AGENT_RUNBOOK.md this stops the loop for this target pending a reviewer. The candidates cluster into three time complexes, not 15 independent events:
- Sector 90, BJD 2460757.18–46 (~6.7 h): the repeat-candidate band. Depth 4575–7401 ppm across 11 merged sub-events against measured reference 7220 ± 102 ppm. QUALITY = 0 throughout, gaps ≤ 2 min. Are the candidates: conditional periods (aliases ΔT/n) 700.5, 350.3, 233.5, 175.2 d... only aliases whose predicted transits fall on retrieved usable data were excluded; the rest stay allowed.
- Sector 101, BJD 2461107.49–79: deepest −0.0078 (up to 188 melded cadences ≈ 6.3 h). BUT the ±1.5 d window carries a 312-minute gap, and the row-axis centroid shifts −0.0596 px against 0.0014 px scatter (~43×) — treat as artifact-suspect until difference imaging says otherwise.
- Sector 37, BJD 2459322.64–249 (shallow, 2–3 cadences): centroid baseline too small to judge.
Kernel-blocker: the pipeline's built checks cannot distinguish these — difference-image centroids and pointing correlation are not built (ANALYSIS_STACK.md), so no evidence level above Unverified lead is possible; do not raise it.
Bottom line#
The calibrated screen recovered the catalogued transit of TOI-3500.02 (BJD 2460056.7063: recovered, depth 7220 ± 102 ppm (catalogue 8095 ppm)). Outside the catalogued epoch the screen left 185 threshold entries forming 44 distinct event(s), 21 persistent (SAP and PDCSAP, two or more baselines). None is vetted; see Screen events. Repeat candidate (unverified lead): a persistent event at BJD 2460757.1825 matches the catalogued transit's depth (4967 vs 7220 ppm), 700.532 d later; 8 of 700 period aliases remain. See Repeat candidates.
This is a pipeline check on a known object, not a discovery claim. Two transits allow only the listed period aliases; they do not fix the period.
Reviewer notes (2026-09-25, supersede pass)#
Superceded by the multi-archive runner: re-run through python -m cygnus.multi on 2026-09-25, steps fetch_products, calibrate_screen, known_signal_recovery, residual_screen, period_aliases, prior_art (ledger fetch_products #1513, calibrate_screen #1514, known_signal_recovery #1515, residual_screen #1516, period_aliases #1517, prior_art #1518). Same retrieved products, same science outputs: entries, depths, k-star calibration and aliases match the production-runner results recorded here; the multi runner additionally records a screen-suitability census and a red-noise systematics model per light curve. The record is regenerated by the multi runner; nothing in the review changes.
Reviewer notes (2026-09-25)#
Evidence level: Unverified lead (not raised by reviewer). Per-complex probes (sectorNN/normalized_series.csv, sectorNN/screen.json):
| Complex (representative mid) | Quality | Gaps | Centroid (in vs out) | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S90, BJD 2460757.3 (repeat band) | 0 flags / 168 cad | ≤ 2 min | -0.0100 px col vs 0.0042 scatter; -0.0046 px row vs 0.0023; baseline n=4 (weak) | clean data, unresolved shape origin; candidates stand as Unverified lead |
| S101, BJD 2461107.58737 | 0 flags / 168 cad | 312-min gap in ±1.5 d | +0.0087 col / -0.0596 row vs 0.0022 / 0.0014 scatter (n=11) — ~43× row | artifact-suspect (gap + centroid); not vetted |
| S37, BJD 2459322.69010 | 0 flags / 168 cad | ≤ 2 min | ~-0.003/-0.006 px, scatter 0 (n=6 baseline — unusable) | inconclusive; not vetted |
The sector-90 band is plausible as a transit-shaped feature but a momentum-dump / scattered-light arc is not excluded — its ~6.7 h width vs the 7.9 h catalogue duration is suggestive, not diagnostic. Surviving alias periods to test elsewhere: 350.4 d and 233.5 d (predicted transits not covered by retrieved data).
Target#
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| name | TOI-3500.02 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| tic | 443666343 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| ra_deg | 186.816884 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| dec_deg | -29.832996 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| t0_bjd | 2460056.706283 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| depth_ppm | 8094.9889377 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| duration_h | 7.9079384 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| tmag | 10.8298 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| catalogue_row_updated | 2025-07-22 12:04:25 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
Products#
| Product | Sector | Covers catalogued epoch | SHA-256 (first 16) | Retrieved now |
|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 64 | True | c4389b8d731f77fc | True |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 37 | False | a49c554877f7022b | True |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 90 | False | 5999cb0ff0ae9579 | True |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 101 | False | dcd7275ffce925f8 | True |
Positive control (catalogued transit)#
| Product | Epoch (BJD) | State | Usable in-transit cadences | Measured depth (ppm) | Catalogue depth (ppm) | Entry offset (h) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460056.70628 | recovered | 238 | 7220 ± 102 | 8095 | -1.35 |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 8095 | — |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 8095 | — |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 8095 | — |
Depth: median PDCSAP residual inside ±duration/2 about the catalogued epoch, against a 2-d running median; the error is statistical only. A depth unlike the catalogue's may reflect dilution, detrending or an epoch/duration error; it is reported, not used as a pass mark.
Calibration and sensitivity#
| Product | k* (sign-flip null) | At grid floor | 90 % completeness depth at k = 5, by duration | at k* |
|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 3 | False | 1h: 10000, 2h: 10000, 4h: 10000, 8h: 10000 | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 2 | True | 1h: 10000, 2h: 10000, 4h: 10000, 8h: 10000 | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 3 | False | 1h: 10000, 2h: 10000, 4h: 10000, 8h: 10000 | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2 | True | 1h: 10000, 2h: 10000, 4h: 10000, 8h: 10000 | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 |
The null result (if any) excludes only dips deeper than the 90 %-completeness depth for their duration.
Screen events outside the catalogued epoch#
Entries merged where they overlap in time. Persistent = SAP and PDCSAP at two or more baselines.
| Product | Mid time (BJD) | Deepest median residual | Max cadences | Flux | Baselines (d) | Persistent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.36380 | -0.00910 | 18 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.30130 | -0.00875 | 16 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.25616 | -0.00843 | 47 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.33394 | -0.00836 | 29 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.18255 | -0.00806 | 7 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.19574 | -0.00776 | 23 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461107.58737 | -0.00775 | 188 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.44158 | -0.00750 | 13 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.46172 | -0.00749 | 3 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.45686 | -0.00734 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.42700 | -0.00724 | 11 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460757.39991 | -0.00722 | 26 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461107.51028 | -0.00686 | 11 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461107.78112 | -0.00616 | 3 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461107.49639 | -0.00583 | 4 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 2459322.69010 | -0.00559 | 3 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 2459322.69565 | -0.00538 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 2, 3 | yes |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 2459324.84562 | -0.00502 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 2459322.65538 | -0.00462 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 2459322.64149 | -0.00443 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 2459322.88871 | -0.00430 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 2, 3 | yes |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.71616 | -0.00633 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.87310 | -0.00613 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.84949 | -0.00602 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460061.38407 | -0.00587 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.80921 | -0.00585 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460759.76664 | -0.00557 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461119.86494 | -0.00529 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460062.02294 | -0.00526 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.78630 | -0.00525 | 3 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.81893 | -0.00523 | 4 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.85782 | -0.00523 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.39533 | -0.00520 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460768.16679 | -0.00510 | 2 | SAP | 1 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.86893 | -0.00509 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461107.48944 | -0.00504 | 2 | PDCSAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2023096110322-s0064-0000000443666343-0257-s_lc.fits | 2460054.55644 | -0.00499 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2025071122000-s0090-0000000443666343-0287-s_lc.fits | 2460759.63192 | -0.00491 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 2459322.74010 | -0.00481 | 2 | PDCSAP | 2 | no |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461102.06416 | -0.00473 | 2 | PDCSAP | 3 | no |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461119.82049 | -0.00469 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461114.52725 | -0.00465 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2026060005000-s0101-0000000443666343-0303-s_lc.fits | 2461101.63636 | -0.00463 | 2 | PDCSAP | 3 | no |
tess2021091135823-s0037-0000000443666343-0208-s_lc.fits | 2459323.00954 | -0.00448 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 3 | no |
None has been vetted: centroids, pointing, background, momentum dumps and other reductions are not tested. Most screen events in TESS light curves are systematics; each is at most an unverified lead.
Repeat candidates#
Persistent screen events whose depth matches the catalogued transit (0.5–2×). Periods P = ΔT/n are excluded only where a predicted transit falls on usable retrieved data and is absent; all others remain allowed. Full per-alias evidence: period_aliases.json.
| Event (BJD) | Depth (ppm) | Reference depth (ppm) | ΔT (d) | Aliases allowed | Allowed periods (d), first 20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2460757.18255 | 4967 | 7220 | 700.5324 | 8 / 700 | 700.532, 233.511, 140.107, 100.076, 77.8369, 63.6848, 53.8871, 36.8701 |
| 2460757.19574 | 5478 | 7220 | 700.5456 | 8 / 700 | 700.546, 233.515, 140.109, 100.078, 77.8384, 63.686, 53.8881, 36.8708 |
| 2460757.25616 | 7088 | 7220 | 700.6060 | 17 / 700 | 700.606, 350.303, 233.535, 175.151, 140.121, 116.768, 100.087, 87.5758, 77.8451, 70.0606, 63.6915, 58.3838, 53.8928, 50.0433, 36.874, 35.0303, 18.437 |
| 2460757.30130 | 7388 | 7220 | 700.6512 | 17 / 700 | 700.651, 350.326, 233.55, 175.163, 140.13, 116.775, 100.093, 87.5814, 77.8501, 70.0651, 63.6956, 58.3876, 53.8962, 50.0465, 36.8764, 35.0326, 18.4382 |
| 2460757.33394 | 7401 | 7220 | 700.6838 | 17 / 700 | 700.684, 350.342, 233.561, 175.171, 140.137, 116.781, 100.098, 87.5855, 77.8538, 70.0684, 63.6985, 58.3903, 53.8988, 50.0488, 36.8781, 35.0342, 18.439 |
| 2460757.36380 | 7138 | 7220 | 700.7137 | 17 / 700 | 700.714, 350.357, 233.571, 175.178, 140.143, 116.786, 100.102, 87.5892, 77.8571, 70.0714, 63.7012, 58.3928, 53.9011, 50.051, 36.8797, 35.0357, 18.4398 |
| 2460757.39991 | 6908 | 7220 | 700.7498 | 16 / 700 | 700.75, 350.375, 233.583, 175.187, 140.15, 116.792, 100.107, 87.5937, 77.8611, 70.075, 63.7045, 58.3958, 53.9038, 50.0536, 35.0375, 17.5187 |
| 2460757.42700 | 6286 | 7220 | 700.7769 | 8 / 700 | 700.777, 233.592, 140.155, 100.111, 77.8641, 63.707, 53.9059, 46.7185 |
| 2460757.44158 | 5863 | 7220 | 700.7914 | 8 / 700 | 700.791, 233.597, 140.158, 100.113, 77.8657, 63.7083, 53.907, 46.7194 |
| 2460757.45686 | 4777 | 7220 | 700.8067 | 8 / 700 | 700.807, 233.602, 140.161, 100.115, 77.8674, 63.7097, 53.9082, 46.7204 |
| 2460757.46172 | 4575 | 7220 | 700.8116 | 8 / 700 | 700.812, 233.604, 140.162, 100.116, 77.868, 63.7101, 53.9086, 46.7208 |
| 2461107.49639 | 4364 | 7220 | 1050.8462 | 22 / 1050 | 1050.85, 525.423, 350.282, 262.712, 210.169, 175.141, 150.121, 131.356, 116.761, 105.085, 95.5315, 87.5705, 75.0604, 70.0564, 65.6779, 58.3803, 55.3077, 52.5423, 50.0403, 35.0282 |
| 2461107.51028 | 5239 | 7220 | 1050.8601 | 22 / 1050 | 1050.86, 525.43, 350.287, 262.715, 210.172, 175.143, 150.123, 131.357, 116.762, 105.086, 95.5327, 87.5717, 75.0614, 70.0573, 65.6788, 58.3811, 55.3084, 52.543, 50.041, 35.0287 |
| 2461107.58737 | 6798 | 7220 | 1050.9372 | 22 / 1050 | 1050.94, 525.469, 350.312, 262.734, 210.187, 175.156, 150.134, 131.367, 116.771, 105.094, 95.5397, 87.5781, 75.0669, 70.0625, 65.6836, 58.3854, 55.3125, 52.5469, 50.0446, 35.0312 |
| 2461107.78112 | 4226 | 7220 | 1051.1310 | 22 / 1051 | 1051.13, 525.566, 350.377, 262.783, 210.226, 175.189, 150.162, 131.391, 116.792, 105.113, 95.5574, 87.5942, 75.0808, 70.0754, 65.6957, 58.3962, 55.3227, 52.5565, 50.0539, 35.0377 |
To advance: compare the two transit shapes, check difference-image centroids and the TOI/ExoFOP record for a period, and escalate to a reviewer (docs/AGENT_RUNBOOK.md). Do not raise the evidence level yourself.
Catalogue cross-match#
TOI-3500.02
- NASA_Exoplanet_Archive (done, 2026-09-25): no match in NASA_Exoplanet_Archive within 30" as of 2026-09-25T00:48:51Z
- TESS_TOI (done, 2026-09-25): 2 match(es) in TESS_TOI within 30" as of 2026-09-25T00:48:57Z: TOI-3500.01 (TIC 443666343, disposition PC); TOI-3500.02 (TIC 443666343, disposition PC)
- VSX (done, 2026-09-25): no match in VSX within 30" as of 2026-09-25T00:49:01Z
- SIMBAD (done, 2026-09-25): 1 match(es) in SIMBAD within 30" as of 2026-09-25T00:49:02Z: UCAC2 19403154 (PM*)
Checks#
| Check | State | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Product integrity (SHA-256) | passed | 4 product(s) checksummed at first retrieval |
| Known-signal recovery (positive control) | passed | BJD 2460056.7063: recovered, depth 7220 ± 102 ppm (catalogue 8095 ppm) |
| Calibrated false-alarm threshold (sign-flip null) | passed | screen run at each light curve's own k* (3, ≤2.5, 3, ≤2.5; ≤ 0 persistent null events outside the veto) |
| Synthetic signal injection–recovery | inconclusive | completeness for the reference box (2000ppm_4h) at each light curve's k*: 10%, 50%, 0%, 40% (pass mark 90%); 90%-completeness depths are in calibration.json |
| Catalogue cross-match | passed | 1 target(s) × 4 services, radius 30″; 4 answered, 0 errored; results in the ledger prior_art table |
| Period aliases (repeat events) | inconclusive | 15 repeat-candidate event(s); first at BJD 2460757.1825, ΔT = 700.532 d, 8 of 700 aliases P = ΔT/n ≥ 1 d allowed by the retrieved data (700.532, 233.511, 140.107, 100.076, 77.8369, 63.6848, 53.8871, 36.8701 d) |
| Alternative detrending | not_tested | |
| Difference-image centroids / blend audit | not_tested | |
| Pointing / jitter correlation | not_tested | |
| Literature (ADS) audit | not_tested |
Reproduction#
python -m cygnus.campaign run campaigns/toi-3500-02.yaml
python -m cygnus.campaign report campaigns/toi-3500-02.yaml
Addendum 2026-09-26: suite-expansion checks#
Re-run on 2026-09-26 with the steps added by the suite expansion (docs/SUITE_EXPANSION.md §7.3) and the corrected moving-object check (TESS-centred SkyBoT positions, distance-aware). The earlier science outputs (screen, calibration, positive control, aliases, cross-match) were compared leaf by leaf and are unchanged apart from timestamps. States and notes below are copied from sky_record.json; the review above is not changed by them unless a note says so.
| Check | State | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Target-to-Gaia identification (proper motion propagated) | passed | TOI-3500.02: Gaia DR3 3471495415361216512 at 0.00" (propagated 2016.0 → J2015.5; 0.04" unpropagated, proper-motion shift 0.03") |
| Stellar priors (Gaia colour and parallax) | passed | TOI-3500.02: Teff 5311 K, R* 0.95 ± 0.08, M* 0.97 ± 0.10, ρ* 1.14 ± 0.30 ρ☉ (dwarf sequence, M_G 4.92, no extinction) |
| Blend and dilution census (Gaia DR3 cone) | inconclusive | TOI-3500.02: 9 Gaia neighbour(s) within 52.5", contamination 10.25%; depth 7220 ppm (measured depth of the recovered catalogued transit); 2 could produce it if fully eclipsed (brightest 3471495419656596352, 3.7", ΔG 2.72); a centroid test is needed |
| Pointing and quality census per event | failed | 21 persistent event(s), 13 clean; BJD 2459322.6415 suspect: scattered light 2 (within ±0.25 d), SAP_BKG z=+14.6; BJD 2459322.6554 suspect: scattered light 2 (within ±0.25 d), SAP_BKG z=+15.2; BJD 2459322.6901 suspect: scattered light 2 (within ±0.25 d), SAP_BKG z=+17.2; BJD 2459322.6957 suspect: scattered light 2 (with… |
| Moving objects at screen-event epochs | inconclusive | 21 event epoch(s) queried in SkyBoT (observer C57, r=600"); no known object bright enough within 63" plus its motion at any queried epoch (supports, does not prove, a non-asteroid origin); 2 epoch(s) not answered |
| Variable-catalogue collision (VSX) | passed | TOI-3500.02: no VSX entry within 10" |
| Object-class guard (SIMBAD) | passed | TOI-3500.02: UCAC2 19403154 otype PM* (star_or_other) at 1.1" |
| Independent repetition (other MAST collections) | not_tested | no light curve from this instrument was fetched (add Kepler/K2/HLSP collections to fetch_products) |
| Independent-epoch confirmation (ZTF) | not_tested | no light curve from this instrument was fetched |
failed on the per-event census means at least one persistent screen event carries an in-event artifact flag or pointing shift (event_census.json); it is a statement about those events, not about the catalogued signal.
Reviewer notes (2026-09-26, vetting reconciliation)#
Vetting rerun 2026-09-26 with the final code. E1 survives every test run (difference image 0.3", 0.7 sigma; 237/237 usable cadences, no flags; red noise 36 sigma below the null; the only inconclusive is the unresolved Gaia neighbour 3.7" away, Delta-G 2.72, which could host the signal). E2 remains suspect: the detrending alternatives disagree (depth 1614-7796 ppm across six detrendings vs box fit 7767 ppm). Timing: reference -> E1 700.62 d, E1 -> E2 350.32 d; nine periods P = 350.3/n d stay data-allowed. Record stays lead (Unverified lead); dossier decision pending.
Source: campaigns/toi-3500-02/vetting/VETTING.md (regenerated 2026-09-26 with the final code) and campaigns/tess-mono-01/LEAD_VETTING_LOG.md.
Reviewer notes (2026-09-26, meticulous difference-image + blend vetting)#
Evidence level unchanged: Unverified lead; the lead now rests on two clean on-target events, not three.
- E2 (S101) is rejected. Its difference-image centroid sits **6.74″ from the out-of-transit centroid at 11.5σ** (E1: 0.35″ at 0.7σ) — the deficit is not on the stamp's flux core. The event carries POS_CORR2 +28.9σ and MOM_CENTR2 +19.2σ excursions, its depth swings 1,614-7,796 ppm across detrendings, and its duration ratio is 0.80. The coherent reading is an aperture-loss artifact: the spacecraft pointing slid during the event and the flux loss mimics a transit. No Gaia source capable of a 7.7 ppt depth exists near the deficit's ~7″ offset (nothing capable between 4″ and 43″). E2 supports no period.
- The E1 "secondary-eclipse" failure was E2 contamination, not a detection. The phase-0.5 windows of the aliases P = 700.62/n (odd multiples of 350.31 d) all land on E2's epoch, so those rows re-measure E2's dip. With E2 excluded the covered aliases are clean (P 35.03: −80 ± 186; 50.04: 313 ± 167; 58.39: 24 ± 167; 87.58: 208 ± 167; 18.44: 206 ± 74 ppm) — no ≥4σ secondary at any alias.
- The 3.7″ blend candidate is excluded as E1's source. The neighbour (G 14.07, ΔG 2.72) shares the host's Gaia parallax (5.21 mas — a co-moving companion) and maps through the S90 TPF WCS to 0.182 px from the placed host opposite the measured deficit centroid; the deficit sits at the stamp's flux centroid, which a 12.5:1 host/neighbour flux ratio pins to the host. The 43.2″ neighbour (ΔG 3.88) is a different pixel region and shows no deep ZTF dips (154 usable points, ±0.05 mag).
- ZTF (IRSA, 2026-09-26): host (G 11.35): 70 catflags-0 zg points, but 0-1 points within ±2 h of any alias-predicted phase — no coverage, not a pass; the 3.71″ neighbour has no ZTF light curve (0 rows — not_tested).
- E1 (S90) passes every check (χ²ν 1.19; shape 1.08 ± 0.06; detrending stable; red noise 36σ; 237/237 cadences; density limit 16 of 17 aliases compatible, shortest 35.03 d — 18.44 d excluded).
Verdict: lead retained (Unverified lead). The alias family widens from the 9 "joint" periods (built on the now-rejected E2) back to the 16 data-allowed aliases of ΔT(ref→E1) = 700.6242 d compatible with the density limit: P = 700.62, 350.31, 233.54, 175.16, 140.12, 116.77, 100.09, 87.58, 77.85, 70.06, 63.69, 58.39, 53.89, 50.04, 36.88, 35.03 d. The 2:1 spacing (ref→E1 = 2 × 350.31 d) makes P = 350.31 d the most economical single reading, but two events cannot fix a period; EB secondaries could still hide in the seasonal gaps for the long aliases. Next test: RV on the host (G 11.35, measurable), ground photometry at predicted alias phases, and the P = 350.31 ephemeris against future TESS sectors.