Drafted by
python -m cygnus.campaign reportfrom the runner's outputs; reviewed 2026-09-25. The escalation and reviewer notes below were added by hand; every other number is the runner's.
Escalation (2026-09-25)#
Positive-control failure is formally escalated, but is consistent with a sensitivity limit: sector 57 covers the TOI epoch (192 usable cadences) and measures 1365 ± 89 ppm against 1437 ppm catalogue depth; however the 90%-completeness depth at k* = 6 is 10000 ppm, so the pipeline's calibrated gate is not sensitive to this transit. No threshold or state was changed.
There is also a repeated ~0.9–1.1% event train at approximately 20.33-d spacing, with ~5–6 h broad profiles in S57, S77, S83 and S84 (representative BJD-like centers 2459871.1, 2460399.7, 2460420.1, 2460562.4, 2460582.7, 2460603.0). It is present in SAP and PDCSAP; the inspected quality/centroid summaries show no decisive instrumental/centroid flag, but no pixel/difference-image audit or independent instrument was available. The same TIC has three PC TOIs, one FP TOI, and a VSX pulsator cross-match. Do not assign the train to TOI-6650.04 or call it a planet/period. Next: reconcile the 20.33-d sequence with TOI/ExoFOP/SPOC DV for all four TIC dispositions, then test the image centroids and seek an independent light curve.
- Campaign spec:
campaigns/toi-6650-04.yaml - Parent queue:
tess-mono-01 - Ledger runs: calibrate_screen #346, fetch_products #345, known_signal_recovery #347, period_aliases #349, prior_art #350, residual_screen #348
- Runner finished (UTC): 2026-09-25T05:06:11Z
Bottom line#
Positive control failed: BJD 2459878.0349: not recovered, depth 1365 ± 89 ppm (catalogue 1437 ppm). Outside the catalogued epoch the screen left 142 threshold entries forming 39 distinct event(s), 14 persistent (SAP and PDCSAP, two or more baselines). None is vetted; see Screen events.
This is a pipeline check on a known object, not a discovery claim. No period is implied by a single transit.
Reviewer notes (2026-09-25, supersede pass)#
Superceded by the multi-archive runner: re-run through python -m cygnus.multi on 2026-09-25, steps fetch_products, calibrate_screen, known_signal_recovery, residual_screen, period_aliases, prior_art (ledger fetch_products #1627, calibrate_screen #1628, known_signal_recovery #1629, residual_screen #1630, period_aliases #1631, prior_art #1632). Same retrieved products, same science outputs: entries, depths, k-star calibration and aliases match the production-runner results recorded here; the multi runner additionally records a screen-suitability census and a red-noise systematics model per light curve. The record is regenerated by the multi runner; nothing in the review changes.
Reviewer notes (2026-09-25)#
Positive control failed formally with the catalogued epoch covered (sector 57, 192 usable in-transit cadences; zero screen entries). The direct depth is 1365 ± 89 ppm vs catalogue 1437 ppm (ratio 0.95), but the per-light-curve k* = 6 calibration has a 90%-completeness depth of 10000 ppm for every duration; the 1437-ppm, 6.43-h transit is far below the screen floor. Treat this as sensitivity-limited, not evidence against the TOI epoch. The 2000-ppm/4-h injection completeness is only 10% at sector 57's k*.
Hand checks of the 14 persistent rows in screen events show a coherent recurring event train, separate from the shallow catalogue signal:
| Sector / BJD-like event group | Morphology | Quality / centroids | Reviewer assessment |
|---|---|---|---|
| S57, 2459871.0627–2459871.2697 (six persistent rows) | One broad ~5–6 h depression, ~0.9–1.0% in both SAP and PDCSAP; rows are repeated baseline/window detections of the same trough, not six events | QUALITY=0, max gap 2 min; representative centroid residuals ≤~1.5σ | transit/eclipse-shaped; not vetted |
| S77, 2460399.6256/.7423 and 2460420.0711 | Broad ~5–6 h, ~0.8–1.0% depressions in SAP+PDCSAP | QUALITY=0, max gap 2 min; representative centroid residuals within ~1.5σ | transit/eclipse-shaped; not vetted |
| S83, 2460562.3867 and 2460582.7155 | Broad ~5–6 h, ~0.9–1.1% depressions in SAP+PDCSAP | QUALITY=0, max gap 2 min; centroid residuals within ~1σ of entry scatter | transit/eclipse-shaped; not vetted |
| S84, 2460603.0480 | Broad ~5–6 h, ~0.9–1.0% depression in SAP+PDCSAP | QUALITY=0, max gap 2 min; centroid within ~1.5σ | transit/eclipse-shaped; not vetted |
| S84, 2460609.0257/.1091 | Two shallow 2–4-cadence entries on a soft ~0.2% low-frequency trough, not the deep event profile | QUALITY=0, max gap 2 min; centroid residuals within ~1σ | drift/noise, not an additional transit |
The deep-event mid-times are spaced by approximately 20.33 d (e.g. 2460562.3867 → 2460582.7155 → 2460603.0480; earlier S57/S77 events align at integer-cycle separations). The spacing is a hand-observed lead, not an orbit fit. The TIC also has TOI-6650.01/.02/.04 PC and .03 FP in the TOI table; the 30-arcsec VSX query returned a DSCT|GDOR|SXPHE source. An eclipsing binary, another known TOI signal, or a blend is a strong alternative. Pixel-level/difference-image and independent-observation checks remain untested. The runner did not assign this train to TOI-6650.04 because its positive control failed; outcome/evidence remain as generated.
Target#
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| name | TOI-6650.04 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| tic | 64837857 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| ra_deg | 338.805332 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| dec_deg | 54.773557 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| t0_bjd | 2459878.034895 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| depth_ppm | 1437.0 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| duration_h | 6.426 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| tmag | 10.0252 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
| catalogue_row_updated | 2025-01-09 16:02:01 | NASA Exoplanet Archive TOI table (copied in the spec) |
Products#
| Product | Sector | Covers catalogued epoch | SHA-256 (first 16) | Retrieved now |
|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 57 | True | 6aa4ca0c14bcf416 | True |
tess2024085201119-s0077-0000000064837857-0272-s_lc.fits | 77 | False | 472fe0fb5951a760 | True |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 83 | False | 2ce9b5b429702c22 | True |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 84 | False | a513194fd134cf25 | True |
Positive control (catalogued transit)#
| Product | Epoch (BJD) | State | Usable in-transit cadences | Measured depth (ppm) | Catalogue depth (ppm) | Entry offset (h) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 2459878.03490 | not_recovered | 192 | 1365 ± 89 | 1437 | — |
tess2024085201119-s0077-0000000064837857-0272-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 1437 | — |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 1437 | — |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | — | epoch not in this light curve | — | — | 1437 | — |
Depth: median PDCSAP residual inside ±duration/2 about the catalogued epoch, against a 2-d running median; the error is statistical only. A depth unlike the catalogue's may reflect dilution, detrending or an epoch/duration error; it is reported, not used as a pass mark.
Calibration and sensitivity#
| Product | k* (sign-flip null) | At grid floor | 90 % completeness depth at k = 5, by duration | at k* |
|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 6 | False | 1h: 10000, 2h: 10000, 4h: 10000, 8h: 10000 | 1h: 10000, 2h: 10000, 4h: 10000, 8h: 10000 |
tess2024085201119-s0077-0000000064837857-0272-s_lc.fits | 4 | False | 1h: 10000, 2h: 10000, 4h: 10000, 8h: 10000 | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 10000 |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2 | True | 1h: 10000, 2h: 10000, 4h: 10000, 8h: 10000 | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2 | True | 1h: 10000, 2h: 10000, 4h: 10000, 8h: 10000 | 1h: 5000, 2h: 5000, 4h: 5000, 8h: 5000 |
The null result (if any) excludes only dips deeper than the 90 %-completeness depth for their duration.
Screen events outside the catalogued epoch#
Entries merged where they overlap in time. Persistent = SAP and PDCSAP at two or more baselines.
| Product | Mid time (BJD) | Deepest median residual | Max cadences | Flux | Baselines (d) | Persistent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460582.71547 | -0.00971 | 175 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 2459871.10023 | -0.00970 | 18 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460603.04803 | -0.00964 | 172 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 2459871.24120 | -0.00950 | 29 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 2459871.06273 | -0.00939 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 2459871.16343 | -0.00928 | 87 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460562.38669 | -0.00906 | 174 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2024085201119-s0077-0000000064837857-0272-s_lc.fits | 2460399.74229 | -0.00884 | 164 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2024085201119-s0077-0000000064837857-0272-s_lc.fits | 2460420.07109 | -0.00828 | 164 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 2459871.07037 | -0.00811 | 7 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 2459871.26967 | -0.00743 | 7 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2024085201119-s0077-0000000064837857-0272-s_lc.fits | 2460399.62562 | -0.00632 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460609.10905 | -0.00425 | 2 | PDCSAP+SAP | 1, 2, 3 | yes |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460609.02572 | -0.00370 | 4 | PDCSAP+SAP | 2, 3 | yes |
tess2022273165103-s0057-0000000064837857-0245-s_lc.fits | 2459871.05857 | -0.00728 | 2 | PDCSAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2024085201119-s0077-0000000064837857-0272-s_lc.fits | 2460420.18776 | -0.00611 | 2 | PDCSAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460572.19869 | -0.00453 | 3 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460572.15077 | -0.00437 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460570.43894 | -0.00392 | 3 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460590.65924 | -0.00390 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460572.15494 | -0.00389 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460590.10090 | -0.00375 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460564.61452 | -0.00369 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460572.10563 | -0.00366 | 3 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460584.23423 | -0.00354 | 2 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460564.74646 | -0.00352 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460578.47030 | -0.00348 | 2 | PDCSAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460590.13632 | -0.00348 | 3 | SAP | 1, 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460564.73257 | -0.00341 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460568.61738 | -0.00331 | 2 | PDCSAP | 2 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460564.53257 | -0.00324 | 2 | SAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460572.08133 | -0.00322 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460572.13133 | -0.00312 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2024249191853-s0083-0000000064837857-0280-s_lc.fits | 2460582.83978 | -0.00309 | 2 | PDCSAP | 2, 3 | no |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460600.86751 | -0.00306 | 2 | PDCSAP | 2 | no |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460590.03702 | -0.00301 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460590.57868 | -0.00298 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460590.69535 | -0.00292 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
tess2024274222008-s0084-0000000064837857-0281-s_lc.fits | 2460609.08822 | -0.00281 | 2 | SAP | 3 | no |
None has been vetted: centroids, pointing, background, momentum dumps and other reductions are not tested. Most screen events in TESS light curves are systematics; each is at most an unverified lead.
Catalogue cross-match#
TOI-6650.04
- NASA_Exoplanet_Archive (done, 2026-09-25): no match in NASA_Exoplanet_Archive within 30" as of 2026-09-25T05:05:49Z
- TESS_TOI (done, 2026-09-25): 4 match(es) in TESS_TOI within 30" as of 2026-09-25T05:05:51Z: TOI-6650.01 (TIC 64837857, disposition PC); TOI-6650.02 (TIC 64837857, disposition PC); TOI-6650.03 (TIC 64837857, disposition FP); TOI-6650.04 (TIC 64837857, disposition PC)
- VSX (done, 2026-09-25): 1 match(es) in VSX within 30" as of 2026-09-25T05:05:53Z: Gaia DR3 2003378084962524032 (type DSCT|GDOR|SXPHE, P — d)
- SIMBAD (done, 2026-09-25): 1 match(es) in SIMBAD within 30" as of 2026-09-25T05:05:54Z: BD+54 2812 (*)
Checks#
| Check | State | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Product integrity (SHA-256) | passed | 4 product(s) checksummed at first retrieval |
| Known-signal recovery (positive control) | failed | BJD 2459878.0349: not recovered, depth 1365 ± 89 ppm (catalogue 1437 ppm) |
| Calibrated false-alarm threshold (sign-flip null) | passed | screen run at each light curve's own k* (6, 3.5, ≤2.5, ≤2.5; ≤ 0 persistent null events outside the veto) |
| Synthetic signal injection–recovery | inconclusive | completeness for the reference box (2000ppm_4h) at each light curve's k*: 10%, 10%, 40%, 70% (pass mark 90%); 90%-completeness depths are in calibration.json |
| Catalogue cross-match | passed | 1 target(s) × 4 services, radius 30″; 4 answered, 0 errored; results in the ledger prior_art table |
| Period aliases (repeat events) | not_tested | catalogued transit not recovered; no reference depth |
| Alternative detrending | not_tested | |
| Difference-image centroids / blend audit | not_tested | |
| Pointing / jitter correlation | not_tested | |
| Literature (ADS) audit | not_tested |
Reproduction#
python -m cygnus.campaign run campaigns/toi-6650-04.yaml
python -m cygnus.campaign report campaigns/toi-6650-04.yaml
Addendum 2026-09-26: suite-expansion checks#
Re-run on 2026-09-26 with the steps added by the suite expansion (docs/SUITE_EXPANSION.md §7.3) and the corrected moving-object check (TESS-centred SkyBoT positions, distance-aware). The earlier science outputs (screen, calibration, positive control, aliases, cross-match) were compared leaf by leaf and are unchanged apart from timestamps. States and notes below are copied from sky_record.json; the review above is not changed by them unless a note says so.
| Check | State | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Target-to-Gaia identification (proper motion propagated) | passed | TOI-6650.04: Gaia DR3 2003378188041736320 at 0.00" (propagated 2016.0 → J2015.5; 0.01" unpropagated, proper-motion shift 0.01") |
| Stellar priors (Gaia colour and parallax) | passed | TOI-6650.04: Teff 6427 K, R* 1.39 ± 0.11, M* 1.27 ± 0.13, ρ* 0.48 ± 0.12 ρ☉ (dwarf sequence, M_G 3.49, no extinction) |
| Blend and dilution census (Gaia DR3 cone) | inconclusive | TOI-6650.04: 65 Gaia neighbour(s) within 52.5", contamination 12.51%; depth 1437 ppm (catalogue depth); 9 could produce it if fully eclipsed (brightest 2003378084962524032, 28.3", ΔG 2.80); a centroid test is needed |
| Pointing and quality census per event | failed | 14 persistent event(s), 8 clean; BJD 2460399.6256 suspect: SAP_BKG z=-5.4; BJD 2460399.7423 suspect: SAP_BKG z=-9.4; BJD 2460420.0711 suspect: SAP_BKG z=+7.7; BJD 2460562.3867 suspect: argabrightening (within ±0.25 d), coarse point (within ±0.25 d), manual exclude (within ±0.25 d), MOM_CENTR2 z=-11.3, POS_CORR2 z=-10.6… |
| Moving objects at screen-event epochs | inconclusive | 14 event epoch(s) queried in SkyBoT (observer C57, r=600"); no known object bright enough within 63" plus its motion at any queried epoch (supports, does not prove, a non-asteroid origin); 3 epoch(s) not answered |
| Variable-catalogue collision (VSX) | passed | TOI-6650.04: no VSX entry within 10" |
| Object-class guard (SIMBAD) | passed | TOI-6650.04: BD+54 2812 otype * (star_or_other) at 0.2" |
| Independent repetition (other MAST collections) | not_tested | no repeat candidate with allowed period aliases |
| Independent-epoch confirmation (ZTF) | not_tested | no repeat candidate with allowed period aliases |
failed on the per-event census means at least one persistent screen event carries an in-event artifact flag or pointing shift (event_census.json); it is a statement about those events, not about the catalogued signal.